Trade up, move, rent it out, or sell and rent
If you own your home now and are wondering whether to stay, sell and move up, keep it as a rental and buy the next one, or sell it and rent instead — and whether you can afford it — the full plan works it out on your own figures: what your home would sell for, what you paid and when, what you still owe and at what rate, your take-home pay, and the home you would move to. Each path runs month by month, side by side.
The five paths
Stay
Keep the home and the loan you have, at your rate; the loan pays off on its own schedule.
Sell and move now
Sell, and buy the next home in the month you choose to move.
Sell and move later
Stay for now, then sell and buy in a later month, at what both homes are worth by then.
Keep as rental
Buy the next home and let this one out at the rent you enter; sell it in a month you choose, or keep it.
Sell and rent
Sell the home in the month you choose, rent at the rent you enter, and invest what the sale frees.
Three ways to time the move
- In the same month. The sale and the purchase close together, and what the sale frees goes toward the next home.
- Sell first. Sell, rent for the months you enter, then buy.
- Buy first. Buy, own both homes for the months you enter, and pay for the overlap from cash, a HELOC on the home you own now (up to 80% of its value, all loans together, unless you change it) or a bridge loan with its fee. Either loan is repaid first from the sale, and a HELOC has to be opened before you list the home.
What it works out
- Cash freed against cash needed. What the sale frees after selling costs, the loan and the tax on the sale, against the down payment, closing costs and moving the next home needs.
- Selling and renting instead. The sale worked out as every sale is, what it frees invested at your return, and the rent you would pay, growing with your rent growth.
- The rate jump, in dollars a month. The new loan at its rate beside the same loan at the rate you have now, and what the difference costs you each month.
- The tax on the sale, at the rates you enter. Selling costs come off the gain; what you paid to buy and your improvements count in the basis; up to $250,000 of the gain is excluded filing single, or $500,000 filing jointly, when you have owned and lived in the home for two of the five years before the sale; and depreciation taken while it was let out is recaptured.
- The rental’s cash flow, at the rates you enter. Rent after vacancy, less management, property tax, landlord insurance, HOA, repairs and the loan payment. A loss is allowed against your other income up to the $25,000 allowance, which shrinks as income passes $100,000 and is gone at $150,000; the rest is carried forward and released when the home is sold; what it saves in a year is capped at that year’s tax, and the rest carries forward.
- The price your figures support. The highest price for the next home that still funds every month and keeps your reserve.
Free, a homeowner’s plan shows what you enter, your equity today, your rate beside today’s, and what the rate jump costs a month. Which path comes out ahead, the cash freed, the price, the sale and the rental come with the Housing Model Pass.
What it does not do
- It does not calculate your tax return. The sale and the rental are estimated at the rates you enter, a gains rate and a rate on extra income (federal and state), and it does not model the net investment income tax or a state’s own rules.
- It does not model a lender’s debt-to-income tests. Whether a lender would let you carry both loans while you own two homes is not something it can tell you; ask before you plan to buy first.
- It does not model the reduced exclusion for a move for a new job or for health; a sale before the two years are up is shown with no exclusion.
- It does not model moving back into a home you have let out.
- It is not a tool for running a rental business or a portfolio of properties.
- It does not tell you which path to take.