Rent vs buy, worked out on your take-home pay
Most rent-versus-buy calculators compare the cost of renting with the cost of owning. That answers which is cheaper on paper. It does not answer the question most households are actually asking: once we own it, what is left in the account each month — and what happens when daycare starts?
Why take-home pay, not salary
Salary is what you earn. Take-home pay is what reaches the account the rent or the mortgage comes out of, after tax, 401(k) contributions, health insurance and everything else your employer withholds. Two households on the same salary can be several hundred dollars a month apart once those are out, and that gap is exactly the kind of number that decides whether a mortgage is comfortable or tight.
So the comparison starts from the figure on your paystub. If you have a text-based paystub, the full plan can read your pay and deductions from it in your browser; the file is never uploaded. A scan or a photo is shown to you to type in by hand.
| A price-first calculator asks | A household-first plan also asks |
|---|---|
| Home price, rent, mortgage rate | What actually reaches your account each month |
| Down payment | The cash you want to keep untouched as a reserve |
| Expected price growth | Loans you are still paying, and the month they clear |
| How long you will stay | Childcare from the year it starts, raises, a period of leave, a car to replace |
What changes month to month
A thirty-year comparison built on one year’s budget misses the years that are hardest. A household’s budget moves: childcare arrives and later steps down, a student loan is paid off, pay rises, someone takes leave. Dated into the plan, those changes land in the month they happen, on every path at once — so you can see whether owning still leaves room in the year the daycare bill starts, not just in an average year.
The three answers worth having
For renting, buying now, renting first and buying later, and — if you are weighing one — a starter home first, the same plan shows:
- The cash to buy, and when you will have it — the down payment, closing costs and moving, at the price the home will cost by then, while keeping your reserve.
- Left each month after buying — what remains once housing, living costs, loan payments and the saving you have committed to are paid.
- Where each path finishes — over the years you choose (thirty unless you change it), split into home equity and the money you can actually reach.
When the two of you do not agree
The rent-or-buy decision often splits a couple: one of you is looking at the monthly payment, the other at what renting costs over thirty years. Both are right about different numbers. A shared plan puts the cash, what is left each month and the long-run finish on the same page, from the same figures, and the printed report keeps it there for the conversation — including which single assumption the answer is hanging on, so you can argue about that instead.
How it compares with other tools
A free cost calculator, an affordability app and a spreadsheet each answer part of this question. Three short pages set each beside The Housing Model, taken from their own public pages, so you can see which asks for what and which shows what.
What it does not do
It does not calculate your income tax — it uses the take-home pay and deductions you enter. It does not tell you what to do: it shows what your own figures say, including when two paths finish too close to separate. It is educational modeling, not financial, tax, legal, mortgage or real-estate advice.