Most rent-vs-buy calculators stop at the house. This one keeps going.
The Housing Model is a rent-vs-buy planner for U.S. households. It checks renting, buying now, buying later or a starter home against your real take-home pay, kids, daycare, car and loans, and shows which one you can actually afford, month by month.
Start with five figures below. Free, in your browser, no account.
Five figures
The numbers below are an example. Replace them with yours — the answer updates as you type.
Numbers it filled in for you
These are the figures a five-minute look has to supply itself. If you know one — the rate you were quoted, your town's property tax — put it in and the answer uses it. Leave any of them blank to keep the stated default.
- When you’re cash-readyWith the Housing Model Pass
- The price at which buying stops beating rentingWith the Housing Model Pass
- How long you’d need to stayWith the Housing Model Pass
Replace any of the example figures with yours and those come with you into the full plan; the ones you leave do not.
The full plan is free to build. The Housing Model Pass adds everything your plan works out on your full figures: when you’re cash-ready, the price your figures support, the price at which buying stops beating renting and how long you’d need to stay, which path comes out ahead and what moves it, and the printable report. It is $59 for twelve months. See everything it includes →
What five figures can’t see — tried on yours
Things that happen to households, tried on the figures above. Five figures can’t know which of these is yours — the full plan takes your own, and shows the month each one bites.
Five figures can’t see your debts, your own childcare costs or a raise on the way. Add yours in the full plan and see whether the answer changes.
Weighing a cheaper place now? The full plan compares buying it first — and moving up, or staying — on your own figures.
This is the full plan's own engine, not a simplified copy of it. The same calculation runs here and in the full plan, so a difference between them comes from the inputs and assumptions, not from two different models. This page asks for five figures and fills in the rest; the full plan asks you.
What it filled in for you
Every number this answer rests on that you did not type, with where it came from. Nothing here is hidden in the code.
What it never asked about
Each of these can change which way the answer goes.
Coming out ahead is not the same as getting through it
The answer above says which path ends richer on five numbers. The question that actually decides it — which paths show a monthly shortfall under your own figures — needs your paystub, your debts, your kids and your town. That is the full plan.
Three paths every time. A fourth if you’re considering a starter home first.
Every path runs month by month, side by side, on the same figures for your household. See them side by side in the sample report →
Rent & invest
Keep renting, and invest what a down payment would have locked up — plus whatever renting saves you each month.
Buy now
Buy now, with the down payment and mortgage rate you enter.
Rent, then buy
Rent for a few years while you save, then buy the same home at what it costs by then.
Starter home, then upgrade
Buy a smaller home first, now or in a month you choose, then sell it and move up later — or stay in it.
Thinking about a second home? Compare buying it now, later, or keeping the money invested →
What a quick rent-versus-buy calculator leaves out.
A calculator answers on a price, a rent and a rate. It cannot see the rest of your household, and the rest decides whether the answer holds. The full plan carries it, each on the date it happens.
Your take-home pay
Typed in, or read off a paystub in your browser. It does not calculate your income tax.
Kids
Dated childcare and school stages, age-banded costs, a college fund.
Cars, plural
A payment now, a replacement when you expect it.
Debts and refinancing
Loans paid down in order; a refinance in the month you choose.
The tight middle years
Year 30 can look fine while year 7 drains your reserve; a path that runs out is marked.
The price your figures support
The highest price that funds every month and keeps your reserve.
What the answer is hanging on
Each assumption moved on its own, ranked by how far it moves the gap.
Nothing guessed
Your own figures are never filled in, and a blank is never treated as zero.
One household, and what the model actually says.
An invented couple, so every figure can be shown in full.
See their figures, and the four answers they get
- $11,500 take-home a month between them
- $4,200 living costs · $4,000 rent
- $450 a month on a $16,000 student loan at 5.5%, cleared in 2029
- $1,200 a month into 401(k)s before take-home, plus $600 from employers
- $60,000 cash · $155,000 invested
- $30,000 they want to keep untouched
- $600,000 home in mind, planning to buy in about 2.5 years
- 20% down at a 6.5% mortgage rate · home prices and rents both assumed to grow 3.5% a year
- a 30-year fixed mortgage · pay grows 2% a year, living costs and insurance 2.5% · upkeep 1% of the home’s value a year · inflation 2.5% · 6% to sell · no mortgage-interest deduction applied
Under these assumptions, Buy now comes out 25.0% ahead of Rent & invest after 30 years.
This household borrows at 6.5%. At 7.24%, the Freddie Mac 30-year fixed average on 29 October 2026, Buy now still finishes ahead of Rent & invest, by $601k in today’s money.
Buy now finishes $712k ahead of Rent & invest after 30 years, in today’s money.
Buy now stays ahead at any price up to about $815k today, and sold after 5 years or more, after selling costs and the taxes on the gains, still comes out ahead of Rent & invest.
Changing rent growth on its own moves the gap between Buy now and Rent & invest by up to $854k in today’s money; no single assumption changes which comes out ahead.
The arithmetic behind the cards
In today’s money, Buy now finishes at $3.56M and Rent & invest at $2.85M: $712k more, which is 25.0% of Rent & invest’s figure. In the 2056 dollars their statements would show then, the same two are $7.47M and $5.97M, $1.49M apart: bigger numbers, the same 25.0%. Rent, then buy finishes $104k (3.0%) behind Buy now in today’s money ($218k in 2056 dollars). The top two are both ways of buying, so whether they buy matters more than when.
Whether to buy comes down to Buy now against Rent & invest: $712k (25.0%) apart in today's money. Changing rent growth on its own moves that gap by up to $854k in today's money ($1.79M in 2056 dollars): at 5.5%, Buy now leads Rent & invest by $1.57M (Rent & invest runs short here); at 1.5%, Buy now leads Rent & invest by $105k. None of the 13 assumptions the panel tests, moved on its own, changes whether buying or renting comes out ahead.
Their two break-even points: Buy now stays ahead of Rent & invest at any price up to about $815k today, $215k above the $600k they are looking at; and sold after 5 years or more, after 6% selling costs and the taxes on the gains, owning still comes out ahead. Sold sooner, Rent & invest does.
Also assumed, and shown in the report
- Nothing in retirement accounts to start with
- $5,000 of moving and setup costs
- 1.8% property tax
- $2,200 a year for insurance
- No mortgage insurance
- Investments returning 6% a year
Everything else is a starting assumption, shown and editable in the full plan. Every figure here is the full plan’s own output for the inputs above. The household is invented; yours will differ. Read their full report → — the same report the Housing Model Pass gives you for your own figures.
Free to build. $59 to see the results.
Building and editing your plan is free, every step of it, and so is the five-minute look.
The Housing Model Pass adds what your plan works out on your full figures:
- When you’re cash-ready
- The price your figures support
- The price at which buying stops beating renting and how long you’d need to stay
- Which path comes out ahead and what moves it
- The printable report
$59 for twelve months, one payment, no automatic renewal, and a full refund within fourteen days, for any reason.
See pricing → Read a complete sample report first →Deciding as a couple? Build one plan together, so you’re the one who brought the real numbers — and you’re both looking at the same ones.