A vacation home or a getaway, worked out on your own figures
A place at the beach, the lake or in the mountains, to use yourselves or to rent out for part of the year: whether you rent where you live now or own your home, the full plan works out what buying it would do to your household. It starts from the place you have in mind, its loan and what it costs to run, the nights you would use it and rent it out, and your own take-home pay, and runs each path month by month, side by side.
The three paths
No second home
Don’t buy it: the money it would take stays invested, and your plan carries on as it is.
Buy the second home now
Buy it in the month you choose, with the down payment and the loan you enter.
Buy it later
Keep saving, then buy it in a later month, at what it costs by then.
How you would use it
- Just for you. The nights you use it yourselves each year. If you rent it out for fewer than 15 days a year, that rent is not taxed and nothing is split between you and a rental.
- Used, and rented out part of the year. Rented for 15 days or more, its costs are shared between your nights and the rented ones, by days. If you use it more than 14 days a year or more than 10% of the rented days, whichever is greater, it counts as a residence: the rental’s deductions are capped at its rent, and what does not fit is carried forward against its later rent and lost when it is sold. Used less than that, the rental share follows the passive-loss rules.
- It can also model letting it all year, with an investment loan if you choose one; its losses then follow the passive-loss rules, and for short stays the $25,000 allowance does not apply.
Paying for it
- A second-home loan, at the rate, term and down payment you enter. Lenders usually ask for at least 10% down on a second home, and the plan says so when you enter less.
- Cash, which is the money the No second home path keeps invested instead.
- If you own your home now, a HELOC on it for the cash at closing: interest only, at the rate you enter, drawing only what your cash above your reserve does not cover (up to 80% of your home’s value, all loans together, unless you change it), and repaid when the second home is sold.
What it works out
- The all-in monthly cost, line by line. The loan, property tax, insurance, HOA, upkeep, utilities and, if you enter it, travel to get there, before any rent.
- The cash at closing. The down payment, closing costs and furnishing, with your reserve kept after it.
- The cost after any rent and tax, at the rates you enter. What it costs a month in its first year once the rent, the tax on it and any change in what itemizing saves are counted.
- What it does to your monthly room and your reserve. What is left each month with both homes’ costs paid, and whether your cash stays above your reserve.
- The cost per night you actually use it. How much less you would finish with than by keeping the money invested, with the second home sold at the end, divided by the nights you use it; enter what a comparable rental costs a night to set beside it.
- The price your figures support. The highest price for the second home that still funds every month and keeps your reserve, with your main home’s costs counted.
- The sale, at the rates you enter. Selling costs come off the gain, and there is no main-home exclusion on a second home, so the whole gain is taxed at your gains rate; depreciation taken while it was rented out is recaptured at your rate, at most 25%.
- Mortgage interest on both homes, under one limit. When you itemize, the interest counts on up to $750,000 of loans for your main home and the second home together ($1,000,000 for a loan taken before 16 December 2017).
Free, a second-home plan shows what you enter, the all-in monthly cost line by line, and how the nights you use it and rent it out are treated. Which path comes out ahead, the cash at closing, what is left each month, the cost after rent and tax, the cost per night, the price and the sale come with the Housing Model Pass.
What it does not do
- It does not calculate your tax return. Any rent and the sale are estimated at the rates you enter, a gains rate and a rate on extra income (federal and state), and it does not model the net investment income tax or a state’s own rules.
- It does not model a lender’s rules: debt-to-income tests, or what a lender says about renting out a home bought with a second-home loan. Ask your lender before you count on either.
- It uses the same nights every year, the ones you enter.
- It does not test for a fair rent or for nights lent to family; those would count as your own.
- For short stays, it does not model material participation, self-employment tax, lodging and occupancy taxes, or local short-stay rules.
- It is not a tool for running a rental business or a portfolio of properties.
- It does not tell you whether to buy.