A rent vs buy spreadsheet and The Housing Model, side by side
The Housing Model began as a spreadsheet: the first version was built for one household’s own rent-or-buy decision. A spreadsheet you build yourself can do anything you make it do. This page compares two published rent-vs-buy spreadsheet templates, as their own pages describe them, with what The Housing Model asks and shows.
Read on 11 October 2026: The Measure of a Plan’s Rent versus Buy Calculator (an Excel file; its page says version 3.2, March 2023) and Quadratic’s Rent vs Buy Calculator template. The Housing Model’s side is taken from this site and the sample report on the same day. Quoted words are each page’s own.
What each asks for
| The Measure of a Plan (Excel) | Quadratic (template) | The Housing Model | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The home | Purchase price, down payment, annual appreciation, mortgage rate; property taxes, maintenance, condo fees, utilities, insurance; transaction fees including agent commissions (4-6%), legal, inspection and land transfer taxes. | Home price, down payment, loan terms, and other relevant financial parameters. | Price; down payment; rate and term; closing and moving costs; property tax; maintenance; insurance; HOA; mortgage insurance; selling costs; home-price growth. |
| Renting and investing | Monthly rent; annual investment return. | Current rent; investment return is included in the renting side. | Rent now and its growth; investment return after fees and tax; cash yield; general inflation. |
| The household | Not among the inputs on the page as read. | Not among the inputs on the page as read. | Take-home pay; living costs; debts in order; a cash reserve; childcare stages; cars; raises, bonuses and leave; retirement ages; a starter home if you are weighing one. |
| How long | over a specific time period; no fixed setting named. | 20+ year projections; it suggests comparing 20 and 25 years. | One to seventy years; thirty unless you change it. |
What each shows
| The Measure of a Plan (Excel) | Quadratic (template) | The Housing Model | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The main answer | Liquid net worth over time for renting and buying, with a break-even year (7.3 yearsin its example); ten charts and a PDF report. | Year-by-year cost breakdowns and a cumulative cost tracker for both scenarios; pie charts of buying and renting costs. | Which path comes out ahead and by how much, over the years you choose, for renting and investing, buying now, renting then buying later, and optionally a starter home first. |
| Break-even | A break-even year, and break-even points for single-variable changes. | Not among the outputs on the page as read. | The price at which buying stops beating renting, and how long you would need to stay before selling still leaves you ahead. |
| What the answer hangs on | Sensitivity of the net-worth difference to key assumptions. | Not among the outputs on the page as read. | Each assumption moved on its own and ranked, with both readings. |
| The monthly budget | Annual housing expense. | Yearly cost breakdowns. | What is left in the first month of owning, housing as a share of take-home pay, where each month’s money goes, and the first month the cash to buy is there with the reserve kept. |
| Format | An Excel download; its page advises downloading the file rather than opening it in Google Sheets. | A template in Quadratic’s own web spreadsheet. | Runs in the browser, on a phone too; no upload; a printable report; a backup to a file. |
| Price | Described on its page as free. | The template’s own cost is not stated; the site offers Try Quadratic free. | Free to build; the Housing Model Pass is $59 for twelve months of its results, with a refund within 14 days. |
What each says about its own scope
The Measure of a Plan’s page says This model only accounts for the financial aspects of your decision.
; its fees include land transfer taxes and condo fees, and a 2023 update added a comparison of standard against itemized deductions for US mortgage interest. The Housing Model says, on every page that matters, that it does not calculate income tax, gives no probabilities and does not tell you what to do; every change to its engine runs an automated suite of checks before it is deployed, and its results are frozen and verified against every saved plan.
If you would rather build your own
A spreadsheet of your own gives you every formula and every cell. The two templates above list the home, the rent and the investment return as inputs; neither lists take-home pay, childcare, a cash reserve, debts, or a buy-later or starter-home path. Those are the figures The Housing Model was built to carry, because they are what decided the question for the household it was first built for.
What this page is
A side-by-side of what each tool’s own public pages say it asks for and shows, with the date each was read. It is not a review and it ranks nothing. If a page named here has changed, tell us at hello@thehousingmodel.com and this page will be corrected. The Housing Model is an educational modeling and decision-support tool. It is not financial, investment, tax, legal, mortgage or real-estate advice.