Compared

NerdWallet’s rent vs buy calculator and The Housing Model, side by side

NerdWallet publishes a free rent-vs-buy calculator. The Housing Model publishes a free five-minute look and a full plan that runs on a household’s take-home pay. This page sets the two side by side, taking each from its own public pages, so you can see which question each one answers before you spend time on either.

NerdWallet’s calculator was read on 5 November 2026 at nerdwallet.com/mortgages/calculators/rent-vs-buy-calculator, where its earlier address now leads; its page says Updated November 2, 2026. The Housing Model’s side was read on 11 October 2026, from this site and the sample report. Quoted words are each page’s own.

What each asks for

NerdWallet’s calculatorThe Housing Model
RentMonthly rent, Rent increase / yr, Security deposit, Renter’s insurance / mo, Broker feeRent you pay now, a month; how fast rent grows. The full plan can hold a rent that is stabilized now and rises at the market rate from the month you move.
The homeHome price, Down payment, Interest rate, Loan term, Closing costs, Property tax / yr, Home insurance / yr, HOA / mo, Additional utility costs / mo, Maintenance and repairs / yr, Selling costs, Home appreciation / yr, PMI / yr (under 20% down)Price; down payment; rate and term (the five-minute look fills in the dated Freddie Mac average); closing costs; moving costs; property tax; maintenance; insurance; HOA; mortgage insurance and when it stops; selling costs; home-price growth.
IncomeNo income entry among the form labels on the page as read.Take-home pay (after tax), a month. The full plan reads the deductions on a paystub in your browser, and dates raises, bonuses and leave.
TaxesTax filing status, Marginal tax rate, Capital gains tax; its methodology assumes property tax and mortgage interest are itemized.No income-tax calculation, by design: it works from the pay that reaches your account. The tax on investment gains, on the home’s gain and on withdrawals are rates you can see and change, and a federal deduction estimate is offered from figures you supply.
Investing and inflationAnnual rate of return, InflationInvestment return after fees and tax; cash yield; general inflation (2.5% to start).
The rest of the householdNot among the labels on the page as read.Living costs; debts, paid down in order; a cash reserve kept throughout; childcare from the year it starts; cars; retirement ages.
How longA stay-length slider, How many years will you stay?, from 1 to 30 years.One to seventy years; thirty unless you change it, and the simple plan asks how long you might live there.

What each shows

NerdWallet’s calculatorThe Housing Model
The headlineAs the page loads with its own starting figures: Renting costs $17,769 less over 4 years.For the sample household: Under these assumptions, Buy now comes out 25.0% ahead of Rent & invest after 30 years. A gap under 5% is reported as too close to separate.
What is comparedRenting against buying: monthly cost, and total cost in today’s dollars, discounted by the inflation rate, broken into upfront, recurring and opportunity costs, tax savings and the money back at the end.Renting and investing, buying now, renting then buying later, and optionally a starter home first: each path’s wealth at years 5, 10, 20 and 30 in today’s money and in each year’s dollars, with an If sold figure after selling costs and the taxes on the gains.
Break-evenIts guide: See if and when you’ll break even from the upfront costs of buying and how your monthly costs compare over time. With its starting figures: Buying starts costing less than renting around year 10.Two figures: the price at which buying stops beating renting, and how long you would need to stay before selling still leaves you ahead (Stay at least 5 years on the sample).
The monthly budget after buyingNot among the outputs on the page as read.What is left in the first month of owning, after the mortgage, property tax, insurance, upkeep, living costs, loan payments and the saving you planned ($2,233 on the sample), and housing as a share of take-home pay against a 35% line.
Cash to buyUpfront costs are in the breakdown.The cash needed on the day, the first month you have it with your reserve kept, and the highest price your figures support.
What the answer hangs onNot among the outputs on the page as read.Each assumption moved on its own and ranked by how far it moves the gap, with both readings shown.
Later lifeNot among the outputs on the page as read.A lifetime view to age 90 when ages are entered, with the years after work.

How each says it works

NerdWallet’s page lists its assumptions under Methodology and assumptions, among them: Our calculator assumes a down payment of 10% of the purchase price.; All growth rates (such as inflation, rent increase and home value appreciation) kick in at year two of the calculation.; for upkeep, Our pre-filled estimate sets aside 3% of your home’s value every year.; mortgage insurance until you achieve 20% of home equity; and Your net proceeds are subtracted from your total cost at the end of each year.

The Housing Model shows every assumption as a labeled field you can change, lists the ones the five-minute look had to fill in for you, and prints an Entered facts and assumptions section in the report. It does not calculate income tax, gives no probabilities and does not tell you what to do.

Price

NerdWallet’s page shows no price for its calculator. The Housing Model’s five-minute look is free; the full plan is free to build; the Housing Model Pass is $59 for twelve months of its results, with a refund within 14 days.

What this page is

A side-by-side of what each tool’s own public pages say it asks for and shows, with the date each was read. It is not a review and it ranks nothing. If a page named here has changed, tell us at hello@thehousingmodel.com and this page will be corrected. The Housing Model is an educational modeling and decision-support tool. It is not financial, investment, tax, legal, mortgage or real-estate advice.

Free to build. Household figures stay in your browser: the plan is built and saved there, with no account, and they are not sent to us or to any provider (a paystub is read on your device). Two things leave only if you do them: notes you send with Send feedback (figures hidden unless you include them) and, at checkout, the price you chose, which goes to Paddle. The Housing Model Pass is $59 for twelve months of its results, the printable report among them.